I have two complaints. First, with its 5mm thickness, this mat is pretty heavy (they also sell a travel yoga mat that is 3 mm thick and weighs less than three pounds). It’s significantly heavier than my usual Gaiam foam mat. That’s because the mat is significantly denser as well, which is my second complaint. In comparison to my other yoga mats, it feels less cushy.
Many yoga mats use soft open-cell foam to make them feel soft and cushy. Reworked neoprene doesn’t contain nearly as much air (it also doesn’t let in nearly as much dust, dirt or bacteria, for you sweaty hot yoga enthusiasts). According to Shields, the density actually provides more cushioning, rather than less. “Soft cell mats don’t actually provide more cushioning, even though it feels like it,” he said. The mat's firmness did make it much easier to balance during standing poses, but my knees and hands would have appreciated just a little more squishiness.
But it’s long past time for outdoor enthusiasts to start practicing the principles that we preach. A lot of the gear that we use to play outside has significant harmful impacts on the places we love, and any way you can reduce that would be helpful (also, regular yoga mats aren’t that great for you, either).
I'd probably keep the Suga mat at home or in my car, for protection from the ground if it took my fancy to do some sun salutations outside, and, yes, for my dogs to lie down on. As a yoga mat, I might prefer to tote other, lighter options to and from class. But as a reminder that surfing and yoga should work in harmony with the environment, and not hurt it, the Suga Mat is peerless.
I told Shields that one of my favorite attributes of the mat is how it smells when I put my face against it. “There’s no off-gassing!” he reassured me. “The binder is organic. It’s made for you.” It’s nice to smell neoprene, but this time guilt-free. If they start making organic, recyclable wetsuits that smell like Taco Bell, this particular surfer and yogi would be set.