We Asked a Savile Row Tailor to Test All the ‘Best’ T-Shirts You See in Social Media Ads

“The smartest T-shirts in the world.”

Made of 95-percent cotton and 5-percent elastane, this T-shirt has plenty of stretch and feels smooth and premium. That quality feel impressed Taub, too, who commented on its “very clean look and construction, with considerate cleaner touches around the neckline.” He was also impressed that “the sleeves have been put in with a double stitch, which is similar to how we would make shirts.”

Available in a classic and relaxed cut, in sizes S–3XL, the fit was a mystery to Mike. “My classic-large was anything but—it was practically see-through once I’d squeezed into it, and Taub pointed out that “despite a nice tight sleeve, it just didn't work for me across the chest and upper back.” Interestingly however, the Relaxed XL fitted more like a proper regular and “created a much nicer silhouette with a pretty spot-on length.”

Jeremy was pleased with the well-cut neckline, but the fit was off. “I have broad shoulders and yet this [size medium] is still too big in shoulder, and the arms too baggy.” He also “hated” the stitched logo on the rear neck.

Chris isn't a fan of T-shirts with elastane in general, not least “because they're much harder to recycle compared to 100-percent cotton." But he was impressed by the fit, which hung nicely, and “didn't make me feel like I was in my gym kit, despite the stretch.”

“We made the world’s first luxury T-shirt in 1908 and have been perfecting it ever since … Our T-shirts are the best you’ll ever wear.”

A British brand dating back 160 years, Sunspel specializes in luxury basics such as this made-in-England Classic T-shirt. They also have mid- and heavyweight options, plus a more premium tee woven from the rarest handpicked Sea Island cotton.

Taub was instantly drawn to the construction of the Classic: “The neckline is just a bit more sophisticated, as it is made of the same cloth rather than just a generic trim like the rest here. The construction is consistent with the others; they’ve not done anything especially unique, but it does feel like really nice cotton and just a little more sophisticated. It is thin, though, so maybe best used as a layer.” But he was “disappointed” by the finishing of the neck, where the seam is left exposed instead of finished smooth like most of the others. “It seems a cheap, quick way of doing it,” says Taub. Mike, a longtime fan of the brand, was left bereft by the comments, noting that “once seen, you can’t unsee the rather ragged finish.”

The softness and feel of the cotton used and the grown-up cut make this T-shirt feel premium. Those of us more used to Fruit of the Loom are in for a treat. The cut is snug but flattering, with an excellent length for all WIRED’s testers, although it’s not especially forgiving for dad bods. And while not an issue if choosing one of the colors available, the white is sheer, and nobody needs chest hair and nipples on show—especially not in the WIRED offices.

Can a $95 tee ever be considered good value? We’ve not been wearing our samples long enough to test durability, but Mike assures us that despite them feeling thin, he has several still going strong after five years.

“As classic as they come.”

Swedish brand ASKET, which translates as “a person who does without extravagance and abundance,” admittedly sounds quite dour, but their minimalist collection of wardrobe staples defines Scandi-cool, and their laser-cut, sustainable manufacturing, and business transparency puts most fashion brands to shame.

Their 100 percent long-staple cotton, 180 grams per square meter T-shirts are available in 18 sizes (!), with long, regular, and short lengths. Taub was impressed by the quality but noticed a few foibles. “It feels more durable than the Sunspel, but it does have the same cheaply finished collar,” he said, “Although they have at least tacked it down. They’ve also skipped some of the features around the neck found on the Son of a Tailor.”

As for fit, ASKET performed admirably, with Mike praising the cut and the “premium, dressy vibe, with a neat, un-flappy fit that I found very flattering.” Chris was also impressed: “It’s a great-fitting tee in a quality fabric. The shorter length offers a smarter silhouette, while the regular length still looks good, albeit more relaxed.” Jeremy was also positive, although ideally, he’d prefer a slightly less boxy shape.

“Custom fit means you get garments perfectly fitted to you, and you only.”

Like Spoke, Danish brand Son of a Tailor purports to whip up the perfect fit via an online questionnaire based on height, weight, chest-to-waist ratio, and so on. They also offer a free remake guarantee, and, uniquely, you can log in to your profile and tweak the chest and waist width, as well as length by increments of 0.4 inches (1 centimeter). Other custom-fit options include your choice of crew or V-neck in classic or single stitch, plus two sleeve options and initial monogramming for no extra cost. It’s impressively comprehensive, and each T-shirt is laser cut in their own factory, and handmade.

Made using 100 percent extra-long-staple Supima cotton in either medium (150 g/m²), or heavy-weight (200 g/m²) fabrics, the lighter of the two feels delightfully smooth—almost synthetic—while the heavier thread count falls extremely nicely while feeling premium.

Initially impressed by the feel and fit, especially the length, Mike was disappointed to find the two weights of cotton T-shirts were quite different in sizing, with the medium being “flappy in all the wrong places.” This could well be a machine error, but it was too noticeable not to mention. No issues with the other T-shirts, with our testers being impressed by both cut, and feel, but all three felt that the neck was just a bit big. Taub also liked the quality of the stitching used. “The overlocking is quite clean,” he said, “and out of the packet they feel soft and luxurious—they’ve taken it slightly further than the others with really nice shoulder and neck detailing.”

“The Perfect T-Shirt”

SANVT (from the German word “sanft” to mean soft, smooth or gentle) uses the AI-enabled Sizekick system, which asks for your height, weight, and build details. And then, just in case you’re kidding yourself, it deploys the camera on your phone or computer to “scan” your dimensions while you stand in your underpants and slowly rotate. This is as undignified as it sounds.

Available in XS-3XL, and in short, regular and longer cuts. After webcam sizing, Chris was given an L/Shorter, and despite being very different sizes, both Mike and Jeremy were told XL Shorter was the way to go.

On inspection Taub noted a “fairly basic construction but a very clean, soft neckline with some nice touches.”

Mike was a big fan, noting the “tee is lovely, smooth cotton that feels very premium—with the body scan getting it right.” Although he "could still lose an inch or so on the length to look properly smart.”

Chris also praised the quality of the fabric and comfort, but the cut suggested by the webcam was “simply far too big for me, which is unsurprising given I would never wear a large.”

The sizing software had originally suggested an XL/Shorter for Jeremy, but this was laughably oversized on him and shows yet more failings in the software. Chris' L/Shorter was closer to acceptable and fitted nicely across the shoulders and arms. “The XL swamped me, and even the large was a little roomy, although the shorter length was good." As with Labfresh, Jeremy isn't a fan of superfluous details and said he'd “unpick the needless label sewn onto the hem.”

“The Original T is the one you’ve been looking for. The quality of the fabric is so nice you’ll actually be shocked. ”

This standout T-shirt for Taub is made from 100-percent Peruvian Pima cotton and "has a smoother, premium feel compared to the others, and should be quite a durable T-shirt.”

Taub goes on to talk about how “the neckline has been thought about with nice binding that adds strength to the fabric. It looks properly finished, and this attention to detail continues along the shoulders, which is a lot of extra work in the factory and more expensive to make.”

Premium construction aside, fit was a mixed bag. Chris' T-shirt felt smooth, and he was impressed with the fit that, unusually for a small, “was noticeably more comfortable around my arms and neckline.”

It wasn't as successful for Mike or Jeremy. Mike felt that while impressed by the feel, construction, and the fit across his chest, “the sleeves were long and loose, it was longer at the back than front, and it all looked a bit baggy. Although maybe on a slimmer physique, this would probably be quite boxy and on-trend.” Similarly, Jeremy noticed the T-shirt was baggy across the chest “just where you don't want it,” which was a shame as “the fabric feels quality and the collar comfortable, even with a sewn-in label.”

“A T-shirt that fits. Properly.”

Spoke, as in “bespoke,” makes a big show of its ability to create something fitted to you. Input height, age, weight, waist, typical size, your general thoughts on sizing up, slim fit trousers, how you’d describe your build, and, for some reason, even how tight you fasten your watch, and the algorithm assigns you a size profile that should ensure a perfect fit every time. With T-shirts, this equates to sizes from S to XXL, with “half-sizes” M+ and L+, plus, slim and regular cuts, and short, regular, and long lengths. Spoke also offers a no-quibble 200-day trial—which, sadly all three of our testers needed to take advantage of.

The quality of cotton is spot on, and Taub liked that “they’ve incorporated cute ideas here from traditional shirt making.” These “clever uses of the trimmings” include colorful hidden stitching and gussets at the hem. But, sadly, the Spoke custom fits were all over the place. One was overly baggy, one uncomfortably tight, and the third had the most peculiar pointy shoulders as if the hanger had been left in. Taub was brutal: “Basically the shape of the sleeve isn't correct for the shape of the armhole.”

Had we tried on the shirts in a retail store, we would never have bought the sizes allocated to us by the algorithm. Chris, for instance, shies away from anything with “slim” on the label, but in this case, it would have fitted him better, as his second attempt attested to. But there’s no escaping that 0 for 3 is a terrible hit rate.

“We've spent a decade obsessing over the perfect weight, the perfect fit.”

Arguably the most sustainable T-shirt brand in the UK, Rapanui uses 155 g/m² certified organic cotton and is GM free. The factories in the UK, EU, and India are powered by renewable energy, all packaging is plant-based, 95 percent of the water used in production is recirculated and recovered, and there’s a take-back policy for old garments that are then recycled.

So you’re guaranteed a warm, fuzzy feeling when you wear the T-shirt, but do you look good? The material is fairly lightweight and lacks the premium feel of, say, Son of Tailor’s Supima cotton, and it doesn’t feel as hard-wearing as the Uniqlo range, but it’s by no means terrible. Taub liked the “nice lightweight feel” but was a bit concerned by the neckline, which “shows a little bit of puckering, like it has been stretched already, but they have put effort into other areas with the shoulder and neck stitching protected.”

The chest, arm, and shoulder fit was true to size for all our testers, although Mike did feel it was a bit “unshapely through the body, while also being an inch or two longer than I'd like.” But in reality, the combination of sustainability, eco-credentials, and exceptional value makes it a great choice for basics.

“Our fit is designed to make you look good by enhancing shoulder width, elongating torso, and increasing bicep fit. Not too tight or too loose. Just right.”

An online-only US clothing brand, Mott & Bow uses Peruvian cotton, and the Driggs tee feels smooth and fine without being sheer like the Sunspel. Available in XS to XXXL, there’s nothing in the way of bespoke options here, but the fit was impressive for all our testers.

Mike reported no under-arm ruching and nicely fitted sleeves and shoulders. While Jeremy loved the feel of the cotton and the fit, he felt it might look better after a few washes. Equal praise from Chris, who liked the fit across the shoulders and not-too-long cut, although the fact it requires a cold wash (instead of the typical 40 degrees Celsius) invariably means it will languish in the laundry basket for quite a long time between wears. But it has been prewashed, so shrinkage should be minimal.

As for stitching quality, Taub said that “the overlocking is clean, and, to me, it feels like a slightly heavier version of the Sunspel,” which is significant, given these cost half as much and fitted our subjects universally well.

“If you’re still searching for that favorite, it’s right here! Already got one? It’s met its match.”

Another Danish fashion house doing cool things with 180-gram organic cotton. Colorful Standard produces basics in a giddying array of hues, with sizes from XS to XXL. Each tee uses ecofriendly dye, is PETA-approved vegan and made in Portugal, and comes prewashed for a softer, broken-in feel.

“In recent years, Portugal has become a real base for made-to-measure quality garments,” Taub said, “and this is nicely produced. Very similar in construction to Son of a Tailor, with nice neck stitching, and protection over the back of the neck that will give the item more longevity.”

For a brand aimed squarely at Gen Z, the basic men’s T-shirt is surprisingly grownup-looking, sitting nicely between the dressed-up luxe of Sunspel and a gym T-shirt, with fitted but not overly tight sleeves, true-to-sizing across the shoulders, and a flattering paunch-concealing drape.

Mike’s only real criticism here, something echoed by both Chris and Jeremy, was that the cut is slightly too long. Jeremy was pleasantly surprised by the fit: “For me it has a Goldilocks neck, perfect on the arms and flattering in the body, and while it doesn’t feel as premium as Son of a Tailor, it’s a great option at a good price.”

“Our goal: the perfect T-shirt.”

A global retailer worth around $9.6 billion, Uniqlo is the biggest brand on test, and with 1,000 retail outlets worldwide, there’s plenty of scope to try in-store before you buy. They’ve got a wide selection of T-shirts, including on-trend oversize designs, and those made using their polyester Airism fabrics, but we opted for the classic 100 percent cotton heavyweight tee (XXS to 3XL), from the Uniqlo U collection. The first thing Taub noticed was the thickness of the cotton used. “It’s not luxurious, and rather heavy-handed,” he said, “But there’s no reason to doubt that this T-shirt will last a really long time.”

Chris loved the cut of this T-shirt, although he downsized to a small for a more fitted look, and unlike Jeremy, who had issues with the collar “that made me look like a Playmobil character,” he felt it worked well here. Jeremy was sold on the overall fit. “The thickness of the fabric and attention to detail makes it feel far more premium than the price suggests, although the roomy arms and boxy shape will appeal to a younger audience.”

Mike wasn’t as keen, preferring a closer cut, but he did think it fitted well across the shoulders and chest. The cotton felt “quite coarse” compared to the rest, and it has zero stretch. Mike also questioned how well the shirts washed, but so far, we’ve had no issues there, and the thickness eliminates the need to iron.