WIRED Asked Real Interior Designers to Rank 10 Fake Christmas Trees
Featured in this article
You can spend hours scrolling through lists of the best artificial Christmas trees and still end up wondering what to buy. How real does it actually look? Is it appropriately full? Does it shed? Are the branches strong enough to hold that lopsided homemade macaroni ornament you’ve hung on your tree since 2004?
We decided to settle the debate once and for all by bringing the best-selling artificial trees from three leading brands into a studio for a blind-judged contest. We got 10 trees from Balsam Hill, King of Christmas, and National Tree Company, then found 10 assemblers to put the trees together and fluff them. Next, our panel of three interior-designer judges assessed the results.
Crucially, the judges didn’t know the brand or price of each tree—they picked the winners based on what they could see and touch. There were some surprises along the way, and we learned quickly that sometimes the gift in the biggest, shiniest box isn’t the best.
Be sure to check out WIRED’s other seasonal buying guides, including the best smart Christmas lights, advent calendars, and stocking stuffers.
Making the Cut
We researched artificial Christmas trees online to see what other publications and user reviews had to say, and then lined up the 10 most popular and talked-about trees.
Among them were Balsam Hill’s Classic Blue Spruce, National Tree Company’s enduring favorite Dunhill Fir, and an Amazon best-seller you can get for under $300.
All trees were the same height at 7.5 feet, and judged under the same studio lighting and free of ornaments. The prices ranged from $170 to $1,700. (All prices shown below are for 7.5-foot-tall trees.) We accepted review samples of seven of the trees and purchased the other three. In the end, we had $9,540 worth of trees assembled in a rented studio.
How We Tested the Trees
The trees were delivered to my home and then transported to a photo studio in Overland Park, Kansas, where 10 testers gathered on a Wednesday morning. Everything, from assembly to evaluation, was monitored and done under controlled conditions to ensure a fair comparison. The assemblers knew which brand and model of tree they had, but were not told about the cost or reputation. Some of the trees came with included gloves to help in the fluffing process, but we issued utilitarian latex gloves to anyone who didn’t have them. Assemblers had an hour and a half to unbox, unload, build, and fluff each tree; most were fully assembled in about 45 minutes.
Each volunteer assembler chose a spot around the studio and was assigned a numbered box. “It feels like Christmas!” said one assembler as the timer started and everyone slicing the tape on their boxes, sending cardboard scattering across the room. Tree stands were built and branches carefully unpacked and snapped into the tree base, then fluffed and bent into shape in time for the judges to arrive. Everyone had the same amount of time to assemble and fluff their tree, all of which were the same size.
How We Scored the Trees
Once the trees were ready, three judges—interior designers from Kansas City-based firm ML Designs—arrived to evaluate them and pick the best fake Christmas tree.
Each judge was given scorecards with a rubric that added up to 25 total points. The judges scored each tree on five categories on a scale of 1 to 5: realism, fullness and shape, branch structure, needle quality, and overall appeal. The goal was to find out which tree truly looks the best when there’s no logo or price tag swaying opinion. In the end, the top tree got 72 out of a possible 75 points while the bottom tree scored 32 (our judges admitted to being on the nice side—only one gave a score of 1).
Meet the Judges
• Maureen Lindstrom is a principal at ML Designs in Kansas City, Missouri, with 15 years of interior design experience.
• Marianne Mayer is a senior designer at ML Designs with 10 years of inerior design experience.
• Jill Connard, also with ML Designs, has been in the interior design space for 15 years.
- More Artificial Trees We Tested
- What Size Do You Need?
- Is a Fake Tree More Sustainable Than a Real Christmas Tree?
- What Is the Estimated Life Span of a Fake Tree?
- Is a Fake Tree More Affordable?
- How Should You Store Your Tree?
- What Is Needed to Complete a Tree?
- What Makes a Tree Look Real?
- When Should You Put Your Tree Up, and When Should You Take It Down?
- How Do You Fluff Your Tree?
- Is it Better to Get Pre-Lit or to Do it Yourself?
- How Do You Put Lights on a Christmas Tree, and How Many Feet Do You Need?
- What Is Flocking and How Do You Do It?
- How Can You Keep Pets Away From Your Tree?
Compare Our Picks
| Model | Score Out of 75 | WIRED | TIRED | Heights Available (in Feet) | Lighting Options | Accessories Included | Shipping | Warranty |
| Balsam Hill Vermont White Spruce | 72 | Extremely full and lush. Realistic texture thanks to a mix of needle types. Upward-sloping branches make ornament hanging easy. Looks full and festive with minimal fluffing | Higher price. Its thickness can make disassembly challenging. | 4.5, 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 15, 18 | Unlit, color and clear LED, clear LED, C7 Multicolor LED, Twinkly brand app-controlled lights | Tree stand, storage bag, protective glove | Free shipping on orders $350+, $10 standard shipping | 3-year limited warranty |
| King of Christmas King Flock | 71 | Realistic “fresh snow” flocked look. Full, thick branches. Comes with a remote to change light brightness and set a time. | No option for colored LED lights. There was some shedding even in this short test. Disassembly is more difficult than setup. | 6.5, 7.5, 8, 9, 10, 12 | Unlit, white LED | Tree stand, storage bag, protective gloves, remote, and foot pedal | Free shipping on U.S. orders | 2-year limited warranty |
| King of Christmas Cypress Spruce | 67 | Full and lush appearance without being too heavy. Well-balanced and sturdy structure. Natural color. | Minimal features beyond built-in lights. | 6.5, 7.5, 8, 9, 10 | Unlit, warm white, and multicolor light LED | Tree stand, storage bag, protective gloves | Free shipping on U.S. orders | 2-year limited warranty |
| Balsam Hill Balsam Fir | 59 | Extremely sturdy branches. Minimal shedding. Full shape and realistic silhouette. | Branches and needles appear waxy up close. Flat needles detract from realism. | 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8, 9, 10, 12, 13.5, 15, 18 | Unlit, clear incandescent, clear LED, color and clear LED, clear fairy LED, Twinkly brand app-controlled lights | Tree stand, storage bag, protective gloves | Free shipping on orders $350+, $10 standard shipping | 3-year limited warranty |
| National Tree Company Dunhill Fir | 58 | Pliable branches make it easy to shape. Classic dark green appearance. Wrapped inner pole adds natural look. Soft needles. | Requires some effort on assemblers’ end to fluff and perfect. | 6, 6.5, 7, 7.5, 9, 10, 12, 14 | Unlit, clear, multicolor | Tree stand | Free delivery on all orders | 3-year limited warranty |
| Balsam Hill Fraser Fir | 55 | Quick and easy setup. Minimal fluffing required. Sturdy branch bases. | Needles feel plasticky up close. Weak branch tips might not support heavy ornaments. | 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 9, 10, 12 | Unlit, clear incandescent, clear LED, multi LED, color and clear LED, Twinkly brand app-controlled lights | Tree stand, storage bag, protective gloves | Free shipping on orders $350+, $10 standard shipping | 3-year limited warranty |
| King of Christmas Yorkshire Fir | 49 | Branches are well-arranged which helps the overall shape. Good color. | Metal trunk is visible even after fluffing. Lacks the fullness and realism for a main display tree. | 6.5, 7.5, 9 | Unlit, white LED | Tree stand, storage bag, protective gloves | Free shipping on all U.S. orders | 2-year limited warranty |
More Artificial Trees We Tested
Balsam Hill Classic Blue Spruce for $799: The Classic Blue Spruce from Balsam Hill has a nostalgic look that many seek in an artificial Christmas tree. However, judges agreed that it didn’t feel premium; Lindstrom noted it reminded her of her first-ever tree as a young adult. Mayer appreciated the brown tones in the needles for added realism, but felt that the tree lacked an upscale feel. The tree’s silhouette loses fullness toward the top, and up-close inspection of the branches and needles leaves more to be desired. Despite qualms, it remains a solid, middle-grade option for those seeking a traditional look. Score: 47.5 of 75
Hykolity Artificial Christmas Tree for $130: This one is one of Amazon’s top sellers, and has a 4.5-star average rating, so we had to test it. It mostly delivered on expectations; judges agreed that it’d be best suited as a budget-friendly option or in a kids’ room. If you look closely, you can see the branch wire, but judge Mayer summed it up nicely: “There’s a place for every tree.” On the plus side, the needles looked pretty realistic, and the lights included were good quality. One assembler noted that each light strand needs to be plugged into the next after assembly, which was a little confusing at first, but otherwise setup was pretty straightforward, and the price tag is inviting. Score: 46 of 75
National Tree Company Dunhill Fir (Pre-Lit) for $361: This one shocked everyone in the studio, especially when compared to its fraternal twin, the non-pre-lit Dunhill Fir, which ranked much higher. Dubbed the “Charlie Brown Tree” by both judges and assemblers, it looked very bare even after lots of fluffing. The top branch wouldn’t sit upright for a star or angel; cords were exposed throughout, and there were large gaps that couldn’t quite be hidden by fluffing. What looked promising in product photos didn’t translate in person, making this one a disappointing pick for anyone hoping for a full, reliable tree. Score: 32 of 75
What Size Do You Need?
A good rule of thumb is to choose a tree that leaves about 6 to 12 inches between the top (with the topper on) and your ceiling. For standard 8-foot ceilings, a 7- or 7.5-foot tree usually looks best. Smaller spaces like apartments or secondary rooms work better with 6-foot or slim trees.
Is a Fake Tree More Sustainable Than a Real Christmas Tree?
It depends on how long you use it. Most artificial trees are made from PVC and metal, which aren’t biodegradable. But if you keep the same tree for more than five years, it can have a lower carbon footprint than buying a real tree every year, according to the American Christmas Tree Association.
What Is the Estimated Life Span of a Fake Tree?
The lifespan of an artificial Christmas tree depends on its quality, materials, and care. On average, a good-quality tree can last 7 to 10 years, while higher-end models may last up to 15 years with proper maintenance.
Is a Fake Tree More Affordable?
Over time, yes. While a quality artificial tree is an investment upfront, you’ll save money by reusing it year after year. Plus, there are no yearly disposal costs.
How Should You Store Your Tree?
Disassemble the tree carefully, compress the branches, and store it in a sturdy tree bag or the original box. Keep it in a cool, dry place like a closet or basement. Humidity or direct heat can cause damage or dust buildup.
What Is Needed to Complete a Tree?
A finished Christmas tree is whatever you want to make of it. You can add a topper, a tree skirt or collar, ornaments, and lights. You can also throw in some ribbon, garlands, or decorative picks for extra texture and depth.
What Makes a Tree Look Real?
According to Balsam Hill, PE (polyethylene) is the preferred needle material for replicating the look of real trees. “The needles of PE trees have the shape, thickness, and mass of a true tree branch,” the website states.
When Should You Put Your Tree Up, and When Should You Take It Down?
It’s entirely up to you! Traditionally, trees go up after Thanksgiving and come down after New Year’s Day.
How Do You Fluff Your Tree?
Start at the bottom and work your way up, using your hands to separate and spread out each branch and tip to fill gaps. Shape branches in different directions for a natural look. It takes some time, but it’s the key to a full, realistic-looking tree. Depending on the tree, you may need protective gloves to protect your hands from poky branches and needles.
Is It Better to Get Pre-Lit or to Do it Yourself?
Pre-lit trees are plenty convenient, but replacing lights can be tricky if they burn out. Unlit trees give you more flexibility to switch up light colors or styles year to year.
How Do You Put Lights on a Christmas Tree, and How Many Feet Do You Need?
Govee recommends about 100 lights per foot of tree height. For example, a 7-foot tree would call for about 700 lights. How many lights per food is dependent on brand; check out the brand we recommend in our guide to the Best Smart Christmas Lights.
What Is Flocking and How Do You Do It?
Flocking is the process of adding artificial snow to a tree. You can buy pre-flocked trees or DIY it by using spray-on snow or flocking powder. Beware! This can get messy, so always do it outside and let it fully dry before decorating.
How Can You Keep Pets Away From Your Tree?
If pets are messing with your tree, anchor the tree securely by using a sturdy, weighted tree stand. If it still feels wobbly, place heavy objects like sandbags or small weights on the stand’s legs to make it more bottom-heavy.
Avoid low-hanging ornaments and skip tinsel, which can be inviting for curious paws. Using a decorative fence or baby gate can also help keep pets away.
Power up with unlimited access to WIRED. Get best-in-class reporting and exclusive subscriber content that's too important to ignore. Subscribe Today.



















